Benny Lucchetti's Pizza

Saverio DiFonzo a month ago

Went to grab a slice on my lunch break recently. Have always loved bennys but this time kinda just left a sour taste in my mouth. Had ordered the jerk chicken special slice which on the menu in the store states chicken, sauce, and bacon, as seen in the picture. It arrived with onions and peppers all over it which I just don’t like. I asked to replace the slice with a cheese one as it’s not stated on the menu those are on the pizza and was told I’d have to pay full price for a new slice. I feel as though if something is not labeled on the menu and it appears in my food why should I have to pay again? Love the pizza here and staff are usually great. Just odd and sucks I had to double pay for one slice.

Jordan Mullan 3 months ago

The pizza slices were as large as advertised. Truly a huge slice that covered two plates. The staff wetr very courteous and nice. The only draw back was the state of the resturant. Every table and seat was covered in crumbs, parmesan, and red pepper flakes. We had to clean our own booth to have a place to sit and it honestly wasn't busy in there. Will definitely try here again though.

Amber Perry 4 months ago

Never again will I underestimate the size of a pizza labeled giant. One of the staff helped me load it into my car. Thank you so much. Pizza was huge and delicious. Definitely will becoming back.

James Kennington a year ago

A must try! Heard about the extra large slices, so we gave it a try. $6 for a slice of pepperoni, and trust me, 1 slice is enough. Floppy, cheesy, NY style 14" slices that come on 2 plates. Added breadsticks to top off the lunch. Will definitely revisit.

Gabrielle White Edited a year ago

I've ordered for pickup through Door Dash and also ordered inside for takeout, and it's official: I love this place! The slices are HUGE and about the equivalent of 3 regular slices from other places and ridiculously delicious. The staff was very knowledgeable about their production process and the atmosphere is family friendly. Even though they were slammed busy they treated every customer with patience and professionalism. The owner should be proud! Also, they have those old timey like sodas and a backroom FULL of arcade games. I'm pretty sure Benny's is going to become a locals' favorite. 10/10 would HIGHLY recommend!